Art of Hosting Transitions

A transition is a process in which the existing system of structures, institutions, culture and practices are broken down and replaced by new ones. This shift is a non-linear process in which a system moves from one dynamic equilibrium to another one. Transitions thus concern large-scale processes that cover at least one generation with interactions between different scale levels.

Transition management has been co-produced by Dutch researchers with a number of government, civil society and business actors in an exploratory way as a model to govern transitions. Transition management is an evolutionary way of steering and of creating the conditions for societal renewal to occur. Transition management involves the creation of experiments from which actors learn. The right initiatives can then be up-scaled at the right moment. The approach is rooted in complexity science and embraces such core concepts as co-evolution, self-organization and emergence.

In practice, the transition management model proposes the following cycle of activity clusters: (1) Problem structuring, organizing a transition arena and developing sustainability visions, (2) Creating arenas, developing transition images, transition pathways and transition agendas, (3) Mobilizing the transition network (finding resources) and executing projects and experiments, (4) Evaluating, monitoring and learning. These activities are initially carried out “in the shadow” of the mainstream or regime, that is, they occur in a safe environment for optimal experimentation and learning. The idea is that the regime protects itself from radical change through incremental adaptation and innovation, similar to the process of autopoiesis. Transition management thus initiates a societal transition.

An arena consists of a limited number of pioneers who are selected based on their competences, background and interests, and who are committed towards the transition goal and approach. An arena is an open, multi-actor network that contains representatives of government, firms, societal organizations, knowledge institutes and intermediaries. Transition management thus addresses social complexity, which is a result of diverse interests and worldviews among stakeholders and which warrants a multi-actor approach.

More than a dozen such arenas have been started up in several countries, such as the Netherlands and Belgium. An international network (http://www.ksinetwork.nl) has been established. But how to host these arenas? How can the Art of Hosting contribute to such large-scale change processes? What is the Art of Hosting transitions?

On masculinity

You're absolutely right, Helen. It seems that, in Chris Argyris' words, the theory in use is at odds with the espoused theory when it comes to emergence. Interesting that George refers to "transition managers". In fact, the transition scholars do not like the term "management", so they do realise that transitions and emergence cannot be managed. Maybe we should talk about transition midwives. But maybe there are some success stories in the Netherlands that differ from my experience. I'll find out...

More information!

Transition Management has a guru, Dutch professor Jan Rotmans, who has a personal webpage www.janrotmans.com and an institutional webpage at DRIFT, the Dutch Research Institute For Transitions http://www.drift.eur.nl/]] at Erasmus University, Rotterdam. The international knowledge network's webpage is http://www.ksinetwork.nl. The most recent, comprehensive review of transition management can be found in the PhD of Derk Loorbach which can be downloaded at http://repub.eur.nl/publications/index/409414244/. In Belgium there are two transition experiments: sustainable building and living (transitie duurzaam bouwen en wonen) http://www.lne.be/themas/duurzaam-bouwen-en-wonen convened by the Flemish Ministry of Environment and sustainable materials usage (transitie duurzaam materialenbeheer)http://www.ovam.be/jahia/Jahia/pid/1602 convened by OVAM, the Flemish waste disposal agency.

Fascinated

Eric, I'm really glad you've brought this field of inquiry to us here. It sounds utterly fascinating... AND it sounds really heavily cognitive, disembodied, intellectual... erm... ah... dare I say masculine?

 

Cool

 

How on earth can we talk about "emergence" when we are sitting around plotting scenarios? Or perhaps my understanding of emergence is hopelessy skewed...

 

I think a dose of Art of Hosting and chaordic presencing is just what the doctor ordered. Let's compare some of the stories of what's happening in the hosting field with the stories coming from transition management. What are the success stories?

More information?

Hello Erik,

This sounds all very, very intersting. Do you have a preferred website, where we can learn about this Transition Management?

And can you tell more about how the hosting - the context setting - the conversation style - is done right now, and if they draw on some (which ones?) competences - practices?